Why 10% Across-the-Board Cuts Rarely Work — And What to Do Instead

If you’re a Financial Controller, Finance Manager, or Accountant, you’ve probably heard this line more than once:

“I want across-the-board cuts — everyone reduces costs by 10%.”

It sounds decisive, even strategic — but does it actually work? More often than not, blanket cost-cutting fails to produce meaningful, sustainable savings. This article explores why and introduces a smarter alternative: Activity-Based Management (ABM).

 

Why Blanket Cost Reductions Fall Short

At first glance, slashing 10% off every cost line seems like a fair and efficient solution. In reality, it often results in confusion, limited savings, and operational strain.

Here’s why:

  • Fixed costs remain unchanged: Rent, depreciation, and utilities can’t be negotiated overnight.
  • Material costs are market-driven: Suppliers don’t lower prices just because you have a new cost target.
  • Financing and telecom costs are contractual: You can’t instantly renegotiate bank interest rates or telecom agreements.
  • Strategic assets don’t relocate easily: Warehouses and factories are chosen for long-term benefits, not short-term cuts.

So what’s usually left? Staff costs.
Positions may be frozen, new hires offered lower pay, and layoffs introduced — hurting morale and long-term productivity.

 

The Smarter Path: Activity-Based Management (ABM)

To achieve meaningful cost optimization, companies must shift focus from cutting costs to managing activities.

The principle is simple:

Products consume activities. Activities consume resources.

Activity-Based Management (ABM) is a comprehensive method for identifying, analyzing, and improving the activities that drive costs. When implemented correctly, it delivers three core benefits:

  1. Customer Value Improvement
  2. Operational Efficiency
  3. Sustainable Profitability

 

Tools That Drive ABM: ABC and Process Value Analysis

Management Accountants play a central role in ABM by applying two critical tools:

  • Activity-Based Costing (ABC):
    A cost allocation method that traces overhead and indirect costs to specific activities, providing visibility into true cost drivers.
  • Process Value Analysis (PVA):
    A technique to evaluate the necessity and efficiency of activities — helping identify which processes add value and which don’t.

Together, ABC and PVA support a strategic cost-advantage approach, allowing leaders to redesign processes rather than merely reduce expenses.

 

Final Thoughts

Cost reduction isn’t just about trimming the fat — it’s about knowing where the fat is, and whether it even needs to exist.

Rather than cutting blindly, ABM empowers finance professionals to cut wisely — aligning cost decisions with business strategy, customer value, and long-term success.

 

Call to Action

Have you experienced across-the-board cuts in your organization? Have you implemented ABM or ABC with success?

Share your insights in the comments. Let’s start a conversation about smarter cost management.

Written by:

M Zubair Syed is a finance leader with over 20 years of experience in FP&A and business partnering across various sectors, including automotive and e-commerce. He currently serves as Branch Accounting Manager at Al Futtaim Motors, overseeing financial management and strategic planning for multiple vehicle divisions. His achievements include AED 1.1 million in indirect cost savings and AED 45 million in working capital release. Mr. Syed is proficient in financial planning and analysis, IFRS, risk management, and digital finance tools. He holds CMA and FMVA certifications, is a CPA candidate, and has a Master's in Accounting and Finance. He has championed digital finance initiatives, enhancing reporting accuracy and operational efficiency through automation tools like SAP S/4HANA and Power BI. His previous roles include Finance Manager positions at Elabelz.com and Sap and Kaps Petroleum Services.

Leave Comment